|本期目录/Table of Contents|

[1]栾国华,李樾杨,李鑫,等.储罐火灾沸溢现象及其控制技术研究进展综述*[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2024,20(6):50-57.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2024.06.007]
　LUAN Guohua,LI Yueyang,LI Xin,et al.Review of research progress on storage tank fire boilover phenomenon and its control technology[J].JOURNAL OF SAFETY SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY,2024,20(6):50-57.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2024.06.007]
点击复制

储罐火灾沸溢现象及其控制技术研究进展综述*
分享到：

《中国安全生产科学技术》[ISSN:1673-193X/CN:11-5335/TB]

卷:
20
期数:
2024年6期
页码:
50-57
栏目:
学术论著
出版日期:
2024-06-30

文章信息/Info

Title:
Review of research progress on storage tank fire boilover phenomenon and its control technology
文章编号:
1673-193X(2024)-06-0050-08
作者:
栾国华; 李樾杨; 李鑫; 李云涛; 储胜利
(1.中国石油集团安全环保技术研究院有限公司，北京 102206；
2.中国石油大学（北京） 安全与海洋工程学院，北京 102249；
3.油气生产安全与应急技术应急管理部重点实验室，北京 102249)
Author(s):
LUAN Guohua;  LI Yueyang;  LI Xin;  LI Yuntao;  CHU Shengli
(1.CNPC Research Institute of Safety & Environment Technology,Beijing 102206,China;
2.College of Safety and Ocean Engineering,China University of Petroleum (Beijing),Beijing 102249,China;
3.Key Laboratory of Oil and Gas Safety and Emergency Technology,Ministry of Emergency Management,Beijing 102249,China)
关键词:
储罐火灾; 沸溢; 热区; 控制技术
Keywords:
storage tank fire;  boilover;  hot zone;  control technology
分类号:
X937
DOI:
10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2024.06.007
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
为更加深入了解储罐火灾沸溢机理及其相应控制技术，通过系统的文献调查，从沸溢现象的研究进展和沸溢现象的控制技术2方面进行分析，从热区机理研究历程、沸溢影响因素等方面对沸溢现象进行归纳，并且从消防控制技术、油面覆盖控制技术等角度出发对沸溢抑制措施进行阐述。研究结果表明：沸溢现象涉及多因素之间的相互关联，热区形成机理是沸溢机理研究的关键点之一，可视化研究能较为直观呈现油品的对流换热行为，进而丰富热区理论；沸溢现象的影响因素较多，沸溢时间预测模型主要是基于初始油层厚度和储罐直径进行拟合、基于经典热波理论和油品本身性质加以修正，其公式适用性较低，对沸溢现象的认识有待加深；沸溢控制技术需进一步完善，目前主要通过阻止全液面火灾发生来间接抑制沸溢，采用油面覆盖等方法直接抑制沸溢的措施仍不够成熟；持续改进沸溢相关的研究模型、补充大尺度实验研究、研发新型覆盖材料、完善消防技战术等是沸溢现象及其控制技术的主要研究方向和发展趋势。研究结果可为深入认识沸溢现象、发展其控制技术、提高相关人员储罐灭火救援能力提供一定参考。
Abstract:
In order to deeply understand the mechanism of boilover in storage tank fires and develop its corresponding control technologies,through a systematic literature survey,two aspects of boilover phenomenon research progress and boilover control technology were analyzed.The research history of hot zone mechanism and the influencing factors of boilover were summarized,and the suppression measures were elaborated from the fire control technology and oil surface coverage control technology.The results show that the boilover phenomenon involves multiple interrelated factors,and the mechanism of hot zone formation is a key point in the study of boilover mechanism.The visualization research can present the convective heat transfer behavior of oil intuitively,thus enrich the theory of hot zone.There are many factors affecting boiover,and the prediction models of boilover time are mainly based on the fitting of initial oil layer thickness and diameter of storage tank,and the correction based on the classical heat wave theory and the nature of oil itself,while the applicability of the formula is low,and the understanding of boilover is to be deepened.In addition,the boilover control technology needs to be perfected.At present,the boilover is mainly suppressed indirectly by preventing the occurrence of fire on the whole liquid surface,and the method of suppressing boilover directly by covering the oil surface is still immature.The research direction of boilover phenomenon and the development trend of control technology are as follows: continuous improvement of the research models related to boilover,supplement of large-scale experimental research,development of new covering materials,and improvement of firefighting techniques and tactics.The research results can provide some reference for the deep understanding of boilover phenomenon,the development of its control technology,and the improvement of fire fighting and rescue capability of storage tanks of relevant personnel.

参考文献/References:

［1］杨国梁,多英全,王振华，等.大型原油储罐火灾多米诺效应概率计算模型及应用［J］.中国安全生产科学技术,2013,9(8):130-134. YANG Guoliang,DUO Yingquan,WANG Zhenghua,et al.Study on fire domino effect probability of large crude oil storage tanks ［J］.Journal of Safety Science and Technology,2013,9(8):130-134.
［2］KONG D P,LIU P X,ZHANG J Q,et al.Small scale experiment study on the characteristics of boilover ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2017,48:101-110.
［3］蔡丽辉.池火灾沸溢早期特性数值模拟研究 ［D］.南京：南京工业大学,2006.
［4］HALL H.Oil tank fire boilover ［J］.Mechanical Engineering,1925,47:540.
［5］BURGOYNE J H.Fires in open tanks of petroleum products:some fundermental aspects ［J］.Journal of the Institute of Petroleum,1947,33:158.
［6］BLINOV V I,KHUDYAKOV G N.Diffusion burning of liquids ［M］.Fort Belvoir,Va:US Army Engineer Research and Development Laboratories,1961.
［7］HASEGAWA K.Experimental study on the mechanism of hot zone formation in open-tank fires ［J］.Fire Safety Science,1989,93（4）:221-230.
［8］BROECKMANN B,SCHECKER H G.Heat transfer mechanisms and boilover in burning oil-water systems ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,1995,8(3):137-147.
［9］NAKAKUKI A.Heat transfer in hot-zone-forming pool fires ［J］.Combustion and Flame,1997,109(3):353-369.
［10］KAMARUDIN W N I W,BUANG A.Small scale boilover and visualization of hot zone ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2016,44:232-240.
［11］TSENG T Y,WU C L,TSAI K C.Effect of bubble generation on hot zone formation in tank fires ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2020,68:104314.
［12］马平川.压力和垫水层沸点对扬沸发生的影响研究 ［D］.合肥：中国科学技术大学,2020.
［13］谭家磊,汪彤,宗若雯,等.油品扬沸火灾形成与强度主要影响因素试验研究 ［J］.应用基础与工程科学学报,2011,19(2):288-296. TAN Jialei,WANG Tong,ZONG Ruowen,et al.Main influence factors of oil boilover fire formation and intensity［J］.Journal of Basi Science and Engineering,2011,19(2):288-296.
［14］KOSEKI H,NATSUME Y,IWATA Y,et al.A study on large-scale boilover using crude oil containing emulsified water ［J］.Fire Safety Journal,2003,38(8):665-677.
［15］董四海,柯学,袁焕萌.水对石油化工储罐沸溢的影响及处理方案 ［J］.辽宁化工,2006(10):598-600. DONG Sihai,KE Xue,YUAN Huanmeng.The influence of water on boiling-overflowing of chemical or petroleum storage tank and treating method.［J］.Liaoning Chemical Industry,2006(10):598-600.
［16］李自力.原油罐火灾沸溢问题实验研究 ［J］.石油规划设计,2001(1):22-24. LI Zili.Experimental study of boilover in crude oil tank fires ［J］.Petroleum Planning and Design,2001(1):22-24.
［17］何利民,段兰贞,郭光臣.原油组分和含水率对热波特性影响的研究 ［J］.石油大学学报(自然科学版),1993(4):60-63. HE Limin,DUAN Lanzhen,GUO Guangchen.The effect of crude oil composition and water content on the heat-wave property ［J］.Journal of the University of Petroleum,China(Edition of Natural Science),1993(4):60-63.
［18］梁志桐.小尺寸油品沸溢火灾的模拟实验研究 ［D］.大连：大连理工大学,2012.
［19］杨大伟,张培红,陈宝智,等.小尺度油罐沸溢火灾发生时间及沸溢特性 ［J］.东北大学学报(自然科学版),2013,34(5):723-726. YANG Dawei,ZHANG Peihong,CHEN Baozhi,et al.Boilover start time and boilover characteristics of small-scale oil tank ［J］.Journal of Northeastern University (Natural Science),2013,34(5):723-726.
［20］李建华,黄郑华,黄汉京.重质油罐火灾热波传播及影响因素研究 ［J］.消防科学与技术,2003(6):463-467. LI Jianhua,HUANG Zhenghua,HUANG Hanjing.The propagation of heat waves and the influencing factors in tank fires of heavy oils ［J］.Fire Science and Technology,2003(6):463-467.
［21］CHEN Q P,LIU X P,WANG X H,et al.Experimental study of liquid fuel boilover behavior in normal and low pressures ［J］.Fire and Materials,2018,42(7):843-858.
［22］KONG D P,ZHAO X T,CHEN J,et al.Study on hazard characteristics and safety distance of small-scale boilover fire ［J］.International Journal of Thermal Sciences,2021,164(4):106888.
［23］PING P,HE X,KONG D P,et al.An experimental investigation of burning rate and flame tilt of the boilover fire under cross air flows ［J］.Applied Thermal Engineering,2018,133:501-511.
［24］PING P,ZHANG J Q,KONG D P,et al.Experimental study of the flame geometrical characteristics of the crude oil boilover fire under cross air flow ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2018,55:500-511.
［25］AHMADI O,SARVESTANI K,ASILIAN M H.Prediction of time to Boilover in crude oil storage tanks using empirical models ［J］.Iran Occupational Health,2020,17(1):697-711.
［26］谭家磊,汪彤,宗若雯.原油储罐火灾扬沸形成时间预测模型研究 ［J］.中国安全生产科学技术,2009,5(5):37-41. TAN Jialei,WANG Tong,ZONG Ruowen.Study of time predicting model for boilover formation in crude oil tank fire［J］.Journal of Safety Science and Technology,2009,5(5):37-41.
［27］CASAL J.Evaluation of the effects and consequences of major accidents in industrial plants ［M］.Saint Louis:Elsevier Science,2017.
［28］樊海燕,李想,孙建刚,等.小尺寸油罐沸溢火灾试验研究 ［J］.低温建筑技术,2016,38(4):156-159. FAN Haiyan,LI Xiang,SUN Jiangang,et al.Experi-mental study of boil-over fire in small-sized oil tanks ［J］.Cryogenic Building Technology,2016,38(4):156-159.
［29］GARO J P,VANTELON J P,FERNANDE-PELLO A C.Effect of the fuel boiling point on the boilover burning of liquid fuels spilled on water ［J］.Symposium (International) on Combustion,1996,26(1):1461-1467.
［30］FERRERO F,MUNOZ M,KOZANOGLU B,et al.Experimental study of thin-layer boilover in large-scale pool fires ［J］.Journal of Hazardous Materials,2006,137(3):1293-1302.
［31］FERRERO F,KOZANOGLU B,ARNALDOS J.A correlation to estimate the velocity of convective currents in boilover ［J］.Journal of Hazardous Materials,2007,143(1-2):587-589.
［32］FERRERO F,MUNOZ M,ARNALDOS J.Effects of thin-layer boilover on flame geometry and dynamics in large hydrocarbon pool fires ［J］.Fuel Processing Technology,2007,88(3):227-235.
［33］CHATRIS J M,PLANAS E,ARNALDOS J,et al.Effects of thin-layer boilover on hydrocarbon pool fires ［J］.Combustion Science and Technology,2001,171(1):141-161.
［34］LABOUREUR D,APRIN L,OSMONT A,et al.Small scale thin-layer boilover experiments:physical understanding and modeling of the water sub-layer boiling and the flame enlargement ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2013,26(6):1380-1389.
［35］KOSEKI H,NATSUME Y,IWATA Y,et al.Large-scale boilover experiments using crude oil［J］.Fire Safety Journal,2006,41(7):529-535.
［36］SHALUF I M,ABDULLAH S A.Floating roof storage tank boilover ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2011,24(1):1-7.
［37］FAN W C,HUA J S,LIAO G X.Experimental study on the premonitory phenomena of boilover in liquid pool fires supported on water ［J］.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,1995,8(4):221-227.
［38］朱渊,史嘉欣,王梅超.基于声呐的油品储罐火灾沸溢、喷溅预警技术:CN113160515B ［P］.2022-05-17.
［39］李玉忠,马伟平.中国石油储备库设计运行技术现状及发展建议 ［J］.天然气与石油,2021,39(3):18-23. LI Yuzhong,MA Weiping.The status quo and development suggestions of design and operation of oil reserves storage depot in China.［J］.Natural Gas and Oil,2021,39(3):18-23.
［40］李斌.大型油罐火灾应急处置指挥原则及方法 ［J］.安全、健康和环境,2022,22(12):52-55. LI Bin.Command principles and methods for emergency treatment of large oil tank fires ［J］.Safety,Health & Environment,2022,22(12):52-55.
［41］TRELLEBORG.Dry Foam［EB/OL］.［2024-05-10］.https://www.trelleborg.com/en/applied-technologies/products-and-solutions/passive-fire-protection/dryfoam.
［42］TSAI K C,KOSEKI H,TSENG T Y,et al.Effects of floating beads on the flash/fire temperatures and occurrence of boilover ［C］//Mary K O’Connor Process Safety Symposium.Proceedings 2016.
［43］RIORDAN J.Vapor barrier for flammable liquid storage tanks:U.S.Patent 8,297,460 ［P］.2012-10-30.
［44］吕东,李晋,王玥,等.一种用于储罐全液面火灾辅助灭火空心金属球的使用方法：CN107376159B ［P］.2020-07-28.
［45］STAMBAUGH B A,BADGER S R.Oil fire and boil over attenuation using buoyant glass materials：US10,561,867B2 ［P］.2020-02-18.
［46］周日峰,管孝瑞,张玉平,等.用于石化储罐的火灾防控和火灾抑制方法：CN113384833B ［P］.2022-08-30.
［47］王秉明,庄梦梦.一种防止原油储罐因燃烧而发生沸溢和喷溅现象的装置：CN203997625U ［P］.2014-12-10.
［48］TSENG T Y,TSAI K C.Hot-zone boilover suppression using floating objects in crude oil tank fires ［J］.Fire Safety Journal,2020,118（3）：103239.
［49］张岩,何淼.原油储罐火灾形式和防止沸溢、喷溅技战术方法运用 ［J］.今日消防,2020,5(4):12-13. ZHANG Yan,HE Miao.Crude oil storage tank fire forms and the application of technical and tactical methods to prevent boilover and spattering ［J］.Fire Today,2020,5(4):12-13.
［50］李建华,黄郑华.油罐火灾沸溢喷溅的控制措施 ［J］.油气储运,2006(12):46-48. LI Jianhua,HUANG Zhenghua.On the controlling measures against the boil-over in oil tank fires ［J］.Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2006(12):46-48.
［51］谭家磊,汪彤,宗若雯,等.油罐扬沸火灾防治模拟实验研究 ［J］.中国安全科学学报,2009,19(1):52-57. TAN Jialei,WANG Tong,ZONG Ruowen,et al.Experimental study on the control of boilover fire of oil tank ［J］.China Safety Science Journal,2009,19(1):52-57.

相似文献/References:

[1]董炳燕,黄有波,孟江,等.障碍物对天然气喷射火影响的数值模拟研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2016,12(1):111.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2016.01.021]
　DONG Bingyan,HUANG Youbo,MENG Jiang,et al.Numerical simulation on influence of obstacle on jet fire of natural gas[J].JOURNAL OF SAFETY SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY,2016,12(6):111.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2016.01.021]
[2]吕国杰,王春翔,李斐然,等.临界态CO2原油储罐火灾灭火性能影响研究*[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2023,19(7):135.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2023.07.020]
　LYU Guojie,WANG Chunxiang,LI Feiran,et al.Research on fire extinguishing performance of critical CO2 for crude oil storage tank fire[J].JOURNAL OF SAFETY SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY,2023,19(6):135.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2023.07.020]
[3]蒋依,鲁义,沈芳,等.环境风下大型储罐火灾火焰特征与热物理性质研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2024,20(5):84.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2024.05.012]
　JIANG Yi,LU Yi,SHEN Fang,et al.Study on flame characteristics and thermophysical properties of large storage tank fire under ambient wind[J].JOURNAL OF SAFETY SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY,2024,20(6):84.[doi:10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2024.05.012]

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
收稿日期： 2023-07-05
* 基金项目： 中国石油天然气股份有限公司科学研究与技术开发项目 (2022DJ6808)
作者简介： 栾国华，博士，高级工程师，主要研究方向为石油石化安全应急。
更新日期/Last Update: 2024-06-25